Crumbl Cookies built its brand on far more than baked goods. 

By investing heavily in social media, community engagement, and interactive features like the Crumbl Flavor Vote, the chain turned a constantly shifting menu and iconic pink boxes into a cultural event fueled by FOMO.

Now, that experience has become harder to justify. 

Customers are increasingly questioning the price, size, quality, and consistency of the products, while others complain about the loss of the excitement that originally made the chain popular.

Prestige wears out; quality stays. 

The business data adds another dimension: average store sales declined in 2025, the chain’s expansion slowed dramatically, and more recent traffic figures and closures suggest the challenges have continued.

Some customers say the cookies no longer feel worth the price

For some Crumbl customers, the problem is no longer simply how much a cookie costs. It is whether the experience still justifies the price.

In a September discussion on Reddit, one customer compared Crumbl’s prices in 2019 with those charged today, highlighting how much more expensive the cookies have become. According to this comparison, the price of a single cookie had increased by approximately 50%, while the cost of a four-pack had climbed by around 60%. 

The price increases customers are discussing are not without historical context. St. Louis Magazine reported that a single cookie cost $3.68 and a four-pack $11.98 when the chain expanded into the St. Louis area in 2020.

Read more: Chick-fil-A pulls a fan favorite, but 3 cities get to keep it

Today, Crumbl Cookies Menu lists typical prices of approximately $4.99 for a single cookie and $17.99 for a four-pack. These are not like-for-like comparisons, as prices vary by location and the menu website is an independent pricing guide, not Crumbl’s official price list. 

Still, they support the Reddit discussion’s broader point: Buying Crumbl has become more expensive, making customers increasingly conscious of whether the experience is still worth the price.

“I have never liked Crumbl cookies a lot, especially given the prices. I can easily buy a freshly baked one at a local bakery for less. All that price for a pink box that I will ultimately end up throwing just does not feel worth the money, and for what, a gimmick or an Instagram post,” Aparajita Chatterjee, a food lover and consumer, told TheStreet.

The complaints are not limited to pricing, either.

Crumbl Cookies has a potentially serious customer problem.

Smith Collection/Gado / Getty Images

Some customers flag frustrating experiences 

In another September discussion, a customer who described visiting Crumbl every week shared a particularly frustrating experience. The customer had prepaid and ordered a cookie for pickup, only to discover that the store had sold it to walk-in customers before the order was collected.

Other customers in the thread shared similar experiences, including inconsistent product presentation and disappointing replacements.

Another complaint points to a gap between what customers can order online and what stores can actually prepare. A former Crumbl employee on Reddit said limited morning staffing made it difficult to prepare all the cookies before opening. The employee also alleged that sold-out items remained available for overnight orders, potentially leaving customers paying for cookies stores could not provide.

For a chain that built its loyal customer base on a special experience rather than just delicious cookies, inconsistencies are almost unforgivable. Customers want what they order and the experience they believe they are paying for. 

The numbers suggest this is more than online complaining

Crumbl was one of the fastest-growing restaurant franchises, but recent numbers suggest challenging times for the chain.

Restaurant Business obtained an internal company document revealing that Crumbl’s August 2026 sales were 70% lower than two years earlier.

“Several franchisees said it was the worst month in company history,” writes the outlet. 

Foot traffic at Crumbl’s more than 1,000 locations fell 32% year over year in August, according to Placer.ai. More than 60 stores have closed so far in 2026, and the company cut much of its franchise support team. Operators warn of an insolvency crisis and say more could close. 

More Restaurants:

That nationwide pullback is now accelerating at the local level. In November, a Danbury, Connecticut, location permanently shuttered after more than four years in business, according to NewsTimes, while a franchisee operating three stores in Louisville, Kentucky, filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy to liquidate its assets. 

“Seeing some stores close and seeing the … loss of profitability and all those kinds of things have been painful for a lot of people. Been painful here at HQ. And at the end of the day, I’m the CEO and the buck stops with me. It’s my fault where we are today,” Jason McGowan, one of Crumbl’s two co-founders, said in a September presentation, according to Restaurant Business. 

Other cookie chains have been struggling as well 

Crumbl is not the only cookie business dealing with challenges. Several once-promising competitors have also encountered serious financial problems, suggesting that the struggles go beyond one brand. 

In February 2026, Pennsylvania-based Taylor Chip filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy after struggling with debt and expansion costs. The company initially tried to restructure, but announced in April that it would close all its remaining stores.

Another example is Please & Thank You, a Louisville-based cookie and coffee chain. It filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in June 2026, seeking to restructure while pursuing a potential sale or new ownership. 

These examples do not suggest that the entire cookie industry is failing to attract consumers, but rather highlight the challenge to sustain a business built around a relatively expensive, nonessential treat, particularly after a rapid expansion.

Consumers have less room for expensive treats, while GLP-1 drugs are changing eating habits

There is also a broader consumer-spending problem. For households struggling with everyday expenses, a premium cookie can quickly become an easy purchase to skip.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture found that 13.7% of American households (18.3 million) experienced food insecurity at some point in 2024. That means they had difficulty obtaining enough food because of limited financial resources.  

At the same time, the growing use of GLP-1 medications is creating another potential challenge for snack and dessert companies.

A June 2026 analysis by McKinsey, drawing on Cornell University research, found that grocery spending on cookies declined 7% in the six months after consumers started GLP-1 medications. Spending on sweet bakery products fell 8.5%.

That does not mean GLP-1 drugs are responsible for Crumbl’s declining sales. But these medications reduce appetite and can change food preferences, potentially shrinking demand for some high-calorie treats.

For cookie chains, the combination is not particularly encouraging: customers are watching their spending more closely, and some are also eating less.

“The cookie business has enough problems with fading novelty. Now you’ve got people on GLP-1 drugs who don’t even want the cookie. That’s a tough combination when your entire business depends on someone deciding they deserve a treat,” RTM Nexus CEO Dominick Miserandino previously told TheStreet. 

Related: Applebee’s and IHOP parent closes 208 restaurants