Target has bet big on private labels, but that’s not what’s driving its turnaround, according to new data from Numerator shared with Chain Store Age.
Consumer goods-related store traffic at Target increased 1.4% for the 52-week period ending Oct. 25 compared to the prior-year period, adding approximately 21 million trips annually, according to the data.
During the same period, consumer goods store traffic declined 3.1% at Walmart stores and 1.5% at Kroger year over year.
That’s good news for the Target turnaround, but the data also included a red flag for Target’s comeback.
“During the analyzed period, Numerator data reveals that branded consumer goods spending at Target increased 3.5%, adding $1.4 billion in annual sales. Growth occurred across purchasing households, trips and units. However, private label spending declined 7%, representing a $500 million loss,” according to Numerator.

Shutterstock
Target gets back to basics
While the loss in private label sales is troubling given Target’s heavy investment in its own brands, the numbers show that CEO Michael Fiddelke’s back-to-basics turnaround is beginning to deliver some real results.
He celebrated the company’s progress during its second-quarter earnings call.
“These early results give us increasing confidence that the investments we continue to make, all in service of our strategy, will support continued growth on both our top and bottom line while making Target not just a place to shop, but a destination for busy families,” he said.
He noted that the retailer just completed the “largest volume of in-store transitions of any quarter over the past decade.”
“And in a testament to the dedication of our team, even with this volume of change, we’re seeing continued progress on inventory reliability and guest satisfaction metrics, which are now reaching levels we haven’t seen in many years,” he added.

Shutterstock
Target removes the noise
RTM Nexus CEO Dominick Miserandino thinks Fiddelke has put Target on the right path by changing the chain’s narrative.
“Target spent two years getting dragged over culture-war noise. They flipped the script by dropping the fluff and focusing on why people actually walk into their stores every week: groceries and essentials,” he told TheStreet.
He also thinks the chain has reclaimed its identity.
“Foot traffic is back, food sales are up, and same-day fulfillment is carrying the load. They stopped trying to be a fancy department store alternative and started acting like a reliable everyday hub.”
Target’s Q3 visits rose 7.2% YoY as the share of repeat visitors reached a three-year high, according to data from Placer.ai.
“Those gains appear to rest on Target’s regulars coming back more often. In Q3 2026, 48.2% of Target’s visitors came at least twice a month on average, up 1.6 percentage points (pp) from Q3 2024, while 8.8% came five or more times, up 1.2 pp — the highest shares of the past three years,” Placer.ai reported.
The research firm sees these numbers as a sign that Fiddelke has righted the ship.
“The chain has cut prices on more than 10,000 frequently purchased items and focused on a more consistent in-store experience, moves that give regulars more reasons to come back. And for a chain that spent much of 2025 trying to win shoppers back, repeat visits provide further evidence the effort is taking hold,” it added.
Target may have changed its focus
Fiddelke did not mention private label brands, a core part of his predecessor Brian Cornell’s plan. That doesn’t mean Target isn’t still focused on its owned-and-operated products — they remain prominent in the chain’s stores — but he’s focused on other things right now.
“Just as importantly, we’re delivering an incredible amount of trend-right newness while also providing outstanding value across the entire portfolio. As we’ve said consistently for years now, all of our business decisions are grounded in a focus on the consumer and providing outstanding value on every trip to Target,” the CEO shared.
Miserandino appreciates the focus on value being the chain’s driving philosophy.
“I think we’re making a mistake assuming private label automatically means discount. When people see Kirkland at Costco, they generally think they’re getting a good deal,” he shared with TheStreet.
That’s not the philosophy behind many of Target’s private-label brands.
“Target went in a completely different direction. It made its private labels fashionable, desirable and, in many cases, a reason to shop at Target in the first place. That was brilliant branding, but it also meant consumers stopped necessarily thinking of those products as the cheaper alternative,” he added.
In the current economy, Miserandino noted, that might not be the right play.
“Now that shoppers are watching their spending, that could be working against Target. It’s almost ironic. Target may have done such a good job making private labels desirable that shoppers no longer see them as a way to save money,” he wrote.
Retail expert Maurie Backman thinks Target has made some mistakes with its private-label brands.
“Target lacks some consistency across its private labels, which may explain why sales are down,” she told TheStreet.
The chain has opted to use dozens of different brand names, and she sees that as a mistake.
“One thing Costco really did right was slap the Kirkland label on everything from tortilla chips to cleaning solution. That cohesiveness, coupled with brand quality, makes Kirkland an easy choice. Target has numerous brands that vary in quality and reputation, and consumers may be too confused to buy them with confidence,” she added.
Target has more work to do
As a regular Target shopper, I never stopped shopping there during any of its so-called scandals. I’d like to see more people working the checkout lanes, as I have walked out without buying something due to the length of the line on more than one occasion, but overall, I have always enjoyed the chain’s stores.
When it comes to private labels, I’m less concerned about price than I am quality. I recently bought some Target shirts and they cost as much as similar shirts from Bass Pro Shop, but they weren’t as nice and haven’t worn as well.
Fixing that seems like a tomorrow problem while Fiddelke resets the brand.
Related: Walmart and Target make a key customer service blunder