Nvidia (NVDA) headed into its Nov. 17 earnings report facing arguably its biggest credibility test in decades.
Yet it walked away with results that caught its naysayers off guard. Heading into the big quarterly filing, the first since founder Jensen Huang abruptly resigned as CEO on Nov. 12, its stock tumbled to $155.46, comfortably below its $243.37 52-week high.
With so much on its plate and facing a myriad of investigations, many on Wall Street braced for Nvidia’s management to scale back on its long-term guidance.
Instead, Nvidia delivered another blowout quarter, raising next year’s growth bar. That said, in a research note shared with me, Morgan Stanley analyst Joseph Moore delivered a verdict on whether the company is “back to business as usual.”
Moore bumped his earnings forecasts across the board and subtly tweaked his 12-month price target, underscoring the tug-of-war between Nvidia’s roaring fundamentals and its compressed stock price multiple.
Why Nvidia’s $115.8 billion quarter, Vera Rubin ramp silenced Wall Street’s doubters
In his post-earnings update, Moore reiterated an Overweight rating on Nvidia stock, while trimming his 12-month price target slightly from $267 to $260. Interestingly, that level still implies over 60% upside from Nvidia’s most recent closing price.
Operationally, Nvidia gave bears almost nothing to work with.
Fiscal Q3 sales more than doubled year-over-year, skyrocketing 103.2% to $115.84 billion (up 20.4% sequentially) and crushing Wall Street’s $108.97 billion consensus by nearly $7 billion.
More Nvidia:
- Microsoft just gave Nvidia shareholders a reason to pay attention
- Nvidia has a stake in SpaceX that came from an unexpected place
- Nvidia’s $12.9 billion deal could shape the AI apps you use
Additionally, Data Center sales led the charge at $107.61 billion, up 110.1% from a year ago, while Edge Computing climbed 42.2% to $8.23 billion.
Non-GAAP gross margin landed at 74.9%, topping the Street’s 74.3% estimate, and non-GAAP earnings reached $2.68 per share versus $2.48 expected.
Even more encouraging, management guided fiscal Q4 sales to $130 billion, a powerful $14.2 billion sequential jump that comfortably beat consensus of $125.3 billion, and hiked its fiscal 2028 revenue growth forecast from 70% to 75%, adding $50 billion in projected annual sales.
On the earnings call, interim CEO and CFO Colette Kress summed up the environment bluntly. “Demand far exceeds supply,” she noted, adding that Nvidia’s next-generation Vera Rubin platform is “off to an extraordinary start,” generating about $20 billion in Q1 production shipments.
Pricing power remains ferocious across older chips, too. “Hopper GPUs have recontracted at up to twice their original price under the multi-year agreements, while the B300 rates have risen more than 60% since their introduction,” Kress said.
At the same time, Board Chairman Harvey Jones addressed the elephant in the room up front, saying that directors have unanimously accepted Huang’s resignation, that the board “does not intend to reinstate Jensen as CEO,” and that Heidrick & Struggles will lead a permanent CEO search.

Morgan Stanley’s bull, base, and bear cases for Nvidia stock
Morgan Stanley analyst Moore expects Nvidia to earn more, but interestingly he’s valuing each dollar of those earnings less.
Morgan Stanley bumped its adjusted earnings forecast from $9.21 to $9.69 per share for fiscal 2027 and from $13.37 to $15.32 for fiscal 2028. But to set his price target, Moore used a separate forecast of $21.04 per share for calendar 2028 and applied a lower multiple of about 12 times earnings, in line with Broadcom (AVGO).
He linked lower valuations across the chip space, uncertainty involving the Commerce Department, DOJ, and SEC, and Nvidia’s leadership transition.
Morgan Stanley mapped out three clear 12-month paths for Nvidia stock:
- Base Case ($260, +67.25% upside): Anchored at around 12 times calendar 2028 EPS of $21.04, assuming a deliberately conservative 56% revenue growth in 2027 and 40% in 2028 as Rubin-Ultra preserves Nvidia’s compute dominance.
- Bull Case ($350, +125.14% upside): Valued at 15 times bull-case calendar 2028 EPS of $23.35 if supply opens up faster, high-margin AI software and services accelerate, standalone CPUs and Groq gain traction, and GPU-powered AI PCs expand the client market.
- Bear Case ($120, -22.81% downside): Set at 8 times bear-case calendar 2027 EPS of $15, carrying a 31.2% options-implied probability, if data-center growth stalls once supply catches up, hyperscalers source custom silicon, or tariffs and export controls bite harder.
What Nvidia’s $668 billion commitment surge means for investors now
Perhaps the biggest risk identified by Moore is the sheer scale of Nvidia’s balance-sheet commitments.
He flagged that total financial commitments and guarantees surged from $530 billion a quarter ago to $668 billion, as also reported by Tom’s Hardware, driven primarily by a $111 billion jump in supply commitments.
He described the buildup as “somewhat of a double-edged sword” because locking up supply secures margins while capacity continues to stay tight, but could weigh substantially if AI spending ever slows.
Kress moved to reassure investors on the call that management isn’t writing blank checks. “As the market matures and additional sources of capital become available, we are rigorously evaluating future investments, commitments, and guarantees,” she said.
For everyday investors, the pricing setup is tough to ignore. Trading at roughly 16.2 times Morgan Stanley’s fiscal 2027 earnings estimate and just 10 times its de-risked fiscal 2028 forecast, Nvidia is priced far below historical tech leaders.
Though negative political headlines will continue to linger until a permanent CEO is named, Moore argues “the most significant multiple compression for Nvidia should be behind us.”
Related: Nvidia just sent a powerful signal to SpaceX stock investors