Suze Orman has been vocal about how selling their home to downsize can be a great opportunity for older homeowners to simplify their finances and save money. Especially if they can use the proceeds from their first home to pay for the smaller one in cash.
Maybe you can afford to buy a smaller house with the proceeds from your sale — but does that automatically make it the best way to spend your money?
You might be better off investing that money to generate retirement income while taking out a mortgage on your new home. It’s an understandable dilemma, and one Suze Orman recently addressed on an episode of her Women & Money podcast.
Suze Orman says retirees should buy their next home in cash
A man in his 70s wrote to Suze Orman to say he and his wife were considering selling their house and moving to a more urban, walkable area.
The husband wanted to invest the proceeds from the sale, then take out a mortgage to buy their new house. His wife thought it would be better to use the funds to buy the next house outright.
Read more: Suze Orman has a sobering warning for older homeowners
“I understand her thinking,” the man wrote. “There is something very reassuring about owning your home free and clear, particularly in our 70s and into our 80s. I also wonder whether at this stage of life, maintaining liquidity and keeping more of our wealth invested might be a smarter financial strategy.”
Ultimately, Orman agreed with his wife that buying the next house outright would be the best financial move.
“We’re not talking about years ago when you could have gotten a mortgage for 2.5%,” Orman said. “We’re talking about 7.5%.”
She’s right about where mortgage rates are at. The average 30-year fixed mortgage rate was 7.45% on Thursday, Nov. 19, according to Mortgage News Daily.
Many people also believe the Federal Reserve will raise the federal funds rate at its December meeting, and that anticipation typically drives mortgage rates up. So, Orman said the couple should be prepared to take on a mortgage rate around 7.5% or 8%.
“Do you think that you can guarantee yourself an 8% return in the stock market?” Orman said.

Why retirement changes the mortgage-versus-investing equation
Historically, the S&P 500’s return has averaged about 10%. But once you factor in inflation, that return drops to roughly 6.6% to 6.8%.
Of course, historical stock market returns are averages, not guarantees. Unlike a mortgage interest rate, which is relatively predictable, investment returns can fluctuate considerably from year to year.
Investing in the stock market and betting on higher long-term returns might be fine for younger investors. But when you’re retired or nearing retirement, you’re in a different situation. You have less time to recover from potential investment losses.
More Personal Finance:
- Zillow predicts grim housing market shifts for homeowners and renters
- Dave Ramsey, Fidelity clash over key 401(k) advice
- Medicare’s 2027 premium puts retirement budgets under pressure
Sure, you can withdraw funds from your investment account to pay off the mortgage later or cover other big expenses if necessary. But if the stock market isn’t doing well, you might have to sell stocks at a loss. There’s no guarantee that you’ll make money, or at least as much money as you want or need.
But by buying a house with cash instead, you remove mortgage payments from the equation. That could free up a significant amount of room in a retiree’s budget and provide more financial certainty.
Suze Orman also said that if a retiree is worried about liquidity, they could take out a home equity line of credit (HELOC) on the house they own outright. So they aren’t completely cutting themselves off from liquidity by buying a house in cash instead of investing.
Why retirees need to consider their surviving spouse
It might make you scared or emotional, but as a couple ages and retires, it’s crucial to think about what happens financially when one person passes away.
A couple may be able to afford a mortgage together comfortably, but what happens when one of them is gone?
“What you have to also remember is that when one of you dies, you’re going to lose one of your Social Security checks,” Orman said. “All kinds of things can happen, so you want to make it so that the person who’s in that home can afford it.”
The surviving spouse will still need to cover property taxes, homeowners insurance, and maintenance expenses, regardless of whether the home has a mortgage.
Can that person also afford to make monthly mortgage payments, especially on only one Social Security check?
Should you buy the next house in cash or invest?
On her podcast, Suze Orman advises a specific couple to use the proceeds from their home sale to buy their next house outright rather than invest the money. But how do you know if that is also the best decision for you? Ask yourself the following questions:
- Do you have enough liquidity? Consider whether you’ll have enough money in emergency savings after buying your next home. If not, bulking up your savings and financing part of your home purchase might be worth it.
- How much would your mortgage payment be? Calculate your potential monthly payment, including principal and interest, and determine whether it fits your retirement budget.
- Could you afford the mortgage on one income? Consider whether a surviving spouse could manage the payments if household income dropped.
- What does your financial planner recommend? A financial professional familiar with your circumstances can help you weigh the trade-offs.
Related: This once-unpopular mortgage is winning over homebuyers