Gambling addiction among Gen Z now runs two to three times higher than in the general population. Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business and a pioneer in behavioral finance, explains why sports betting and prediction market apps are putting young adults one tap away from addiction.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Professor, so great to see you. Thanks for joining us on the program this morning.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

My pleasure, Jeffrey.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

So we’re talking this morning about sports betting, and it’s no secret that it’s allowed in, I think, 38 states where people can actually go out and bet. But what I’ve learned in reading, and I’m interested in your perspective, younger adults, 18 to 21, have been trading billions of on prediction markets like Cali. I want to get your reaction to that and get some insight.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

So my sense is that this is a very big deal for American youth. And just to put it into context, it’s important to have fun. There are lots of ways we can have fun.

And sometimes the ways we have fun aren’t dangerous. I think that sports betting and prediction markets are not dangerous for many kids, but for many kids, they’re extremely dangerous. And the telltale sign is really the rates of gambling addiction that we see in the age group you identified.

So for Gen Z, what you find is that gambling addiction rates now, with the advent of apps that allow you to do prediction market bets and sports betting in particular, are two to three times the average in the general population. That’s telling us something, because Gen Z is the future of this country. And the future of this country is looking to be highly problematic in terms of risks.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

So if I may follow up on that just real quick, and then you can jump back in with your comment, why is this attractive? I mean, I can see like the, you know, we can talk about the endorphins and the things that kind of get, I guess, triggered in our brains from doing this. But why is this so attractive to this younger generation relative to someone like myself, who’s a Gen Xer?

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

Yeah, I think that it’s really ease of access. Well, there are two things. One is ease of access.

And the other is that, unlike our generations, I’m baby boomer, you’re Gen X. We haven’t been born and raised in the age of social media. Yeah, but these kids have, and their brains are wired differently as a result.

And sports betting and prediction market betting is going to change their brains even more. So that’s the reason why it’s different. And apps give you ease of access.

So it’s as easy as one, two, three, to engage in this stuff. It was simply harder to do for people who are further along in the, along the age spectrum.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Yeah, I don’t remember doing this as a kid. I remember gambling for Starburst candidly in high school, probably not as invasive as what we’re talking about this morning. Are the, how are the sports betting companies or are the sport, let me ask it this way, are the sports betting companies taking advantage of the fear of missing out?

These, all these things in order to, look, boost their bottom line. It’s a business after all. So are they taking advantage of this generation using different tactics, techniques that maybe have been learned through social media?

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

The techniques are actually old, well-known. So casino gamble, gambling institutions know what, have that whole menu in front of them. And I think that the prediction markets firms are, you are exploiting the same techniques.

So it’s an old story. It’s just that in a world of social media and apps, there’s ease of access and people can do it individually. You don’t have to travel to a casino.

You can do it from your phone. That’s really what the key difference is. But the answer to your, the short answer to your question is yes, they’re profit maximizing institutions.

So they’re interested in doing what capitalist enterprises seek to do by any means. And in that respect, they’re no different. It’s just that the nature of the activity can be highly problematic for a lot of people, especially young kids who are at an age where their brains are still changing in important ways.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

18 is technically an adult, but let me ask this about parents. What can parents do, assuming that, or a guardian or a loved one, what can they do? I guess they could theoretically take the phone away, but if you’re 18 years old, you can go out by your own phone.

So what can they do to kind of shape or reshape the thinking of their young, not young, but their, their young adult children? Yeah.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

Yeah. It’s well, so the first thing is know what’s going on to the extent that you can. I think that, you know, kids who are doing this and are doing it in ways that are problematic, so that it’s severe risk-taking rather than mild or moderate, will, will tend to hide it.

So parents need to be on the lookout, look out to see, for example, whether performance in school is deteriorating, on the lookout to see whether debt is piling up on a credit card, looking out to see whether their kids are becoming withdrawn because this type of activity tends to be a solo activity. So our social activities, participation in social activities going down, these are all warning signs that something might be going on. So, so the need to monitor is really critical for, for, for parents, guardians, and, and, and loved ones.

Now, once you know that there’s something going on for kids of that age, it is important to understand what works and what doesn’t for most kids. Hard confrontation, you know, it’s just going to be like prohibition in the 1930s.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

That’s right. They would go to, what do they call those? They would go to during pro, I mean, it didn’t, it was the opposite effect.

People would go to the speakeasies, right? And they would just get, they were just underground and people would drink. It had no effect, had the opposite effect.

Sorry, go ahead.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

That’s okay. So, so, you know, so you have to know there’s a, you can’t play hardball. You have to play softball.

Softball means being careful. You have to engage in finessing types of activities. You have to be indirect.

You have to sort of say, you know, that you’ve heard that, you know, that some kids are getting into difficulty because they’re engaged in excessive sports betting. You know, you know, are any of your friends, do you know any, anybody who’s in this kind of situation? So you approach it indirectly.

And if you can get your kids to open up a little bit and talk about the fact they’re sport, they’re engaged in sports betting, then you sort of ask questions that are informative without being accusatory. Oh, you know, is it the sort of thing where you, you know, you keep track of your winners and losers. So you try and gently dig down deeper and deeper step by step.

You have to condition your kids so that they don’t feel threatened as you lead them down little by little down a path of inquiry to try and help them. But, you know, for many kids who are in the, in the severe category, you know, they’ll try and hide it. And in many ways, they’ll be hiding the depth of the problem from themselves.

You know, you that’s, that’s typically is what happens for, you know, people who really do fall into an addiction trap.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Let me ask you, you know, these are for profit companies, these prediction companies, but in any capital, you know, our society, we have government. And is there a role for the government here? And the reason I bring this up is when I turned out, I was watching the Baltimore Ravens, unfortunately, this weekend, or on Monday, and their sports betting on pretty much in any NFL broadcast, I’m assuming I don’t watch basketball, but I’m assuming it’s the NBA, it’s the NHL.

Is there a role for the government where it’s federal, state, local, in terms of guardrails, referees, to use that analogy, this promotion of these things, because it would seem to me that if you’re promoting, and you’re, again, targeting certain populations of people, that that might be an issue.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

So there are going to be different views in terms of that particular question, but I will, I’ll just give you my own. So my own is, there is definitely a role for government. And we just shouldn’t expect government will solve the problem in the same way that there’s a drug problem in the country, and government has not solved the problem with the war on drugs.

But it can make things easier, and it can provide protection to more people than would happen otherwise. So you can make things better. And I think that the way to make things better is the way we make things better in securities markets.

We’ve gotten these very important acts that were passed a century ago that are still in effect today. Let’s say, for example, that when investors open up accounts with brokers, brokers check for suitability. Are the type of securities that an investor might want to play the market with, are they suitable for the investor?

The broker has to ensure that that’s the case. So there are a series of hurdles to pass before you can legally undertake the activity. And so I think those kinds of regulations could help.

Education, you know, is also important. And I’ll just tell you that there are social solutions as well as government solutions. And by that I mean, get people to participate in clubs and understand the kids who are most at risk are guys, and they’re young.

So what you’d like to have is a well-balanced prediction market club. Don’t try and eliminate the activity, try and structure it so that it’s safer. Mixed groups, male and female, also mixed by age.

Have a few older folks in there, by older I mean like 26 or 27, if you’ve got 18-year-olds playing, to provide some real adult voices into the mix. And what you’ll find, and the research shows this, is that mixed groups take more prudent risks and they perform better over time because the different mixes tend to offset each other. And that can really help.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

Well, and that’s a really good point. You know, you can have government, you can have for-profit, and you can have community-based or social services. Would you expect this to be in like a school environment?

So K-12, not K-12, but like high school, junior high school, would that be the right environment? Or would it be like a club, for example, the Boys and Girls Clubs of America or the Boy Scouts, those types of external clubs? Sorry.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business

I haven’t thought about that deeply, so I’ll just give you my first reaction. My initial reaction is keep it out of the schools. Okay.

Okay. And so make it external. But don’t not talk about it in school.

Just don’t have it be officially sanctioned within the educational system. And encourage it that, you know, it’s a sort of a good civic thing. Now, I just worry, you know, if you get kids hooked on it too quickly, because it’s a school activity, you know, it can be dangerous.

You know, and I’ll just say, what we know is that kids who are raised in families, where there’s a lot of bedding that takes place, they wind up not being as concerned. You don’t have the negative signals that say, watch out, because they become used to it. It feels normal to them.

And it’s okay for a lot of kids, but for kids who are susceptible to gambling addiction, it’s not okay. And so encouraging the activity too early, you won’t be able to stop it. But if you say it’s okay, then you’ll wind up with the situation being worse than it needs to be.

So you need to be prudent in the way that you structure it.

Jeffrey Snyder, Broadcast Retirement Network

I think this is the modern day, I’m trying to think as a kid, you know, growing up, like smoking cigarettes, drinking, you know, those are the, or doing the drugs, you know, when I was growing up in the 70s and 80s, that I think it’s kind of analogous to that. But those kids are under way more pressure. I, you know, I really feel for the parents.

Hirsh, we’re going to have to leave it there. Really great insight. I think it’s, you know, this is a big issue that we’re going to have to work through as a society.

And I guess we’ll see how it all unfolds. Thanks so much for joining us. And look, we look forward to having you back on the program again very soon.

Hersh Shefrin, Mario L. Belotti Professor of Finance at Santa Clara University’s Leavey School of Business Thanks so much, Jeffrey. Enjoyed being with you