The oil market is delivering a harsh reminder to investors: geopolitical risk may outrun fundamentals.
Brent oil temporarily spiked to about $126 a barrel before tumbling as markets responded to rising U.S.-Iran tensions and worries of more disruption near the Strait of Hormuz.
By the conclusion of the session, Brent pulled back to about $114 while West Texas Intermediate stabilized at $105.
That reversal may offer comfort. But for investors, the greater news is what continued high oil prices may imply for energy companies such as Exxon Mobil (XOM) and Chevron (CVX) and oil-linked ETFs like United States Oil Fund (USO).
Exxon was last trading at roughly $152.75 and Chevron at around $190.63, although both fell in the last session. USO, which monitors oil futures, fell around 2.9 percent to $142.80.
Oil stocks gain a new catalyst from Iran tensions
On the bullish side, the argument for oil equities is straightforward.
Major producers with scale and disciplined capital investment and dividend programs may earn better cash flow when petroleum prices are high.
That puts firms like Exxon, Chevron, Occidental Petroleum (OXY), ConocoPhillips (COP) and the Energy Select Sector SPDR Fund (XLE) back on investor watch lists.
The concern is that this is not a clean oil rally.
OPEC+ agreed to a small increase in the June output quota of 188,000 bpd, Reuters reported, but persistent problems related to the Iran war and the closing of the Strait of Hormuz restrict how much more oil can really get to the market.
That matters because around one-fifth of the world’s oil and gas traffic passes through the Strait of Hormuz.
Exxon was trading at $152.75 recently, while Chevron was at $190.63 and Occidental at $58.71. USO was trading at $142.80 after sliding almost 3%.
This divergence in high crude and turbulent energy equities suggests investors aren’t just buying every oil news item.
They are attempting to price in the duration of the disruption.
Exxon, Chevron face complicated setup
The tough issue is that higher oil doesn’t always indicate all oil stocks will go higher.
Exxon and Chevron both declined in the most recent session despite higher oil prices, showing investors are also tracking profit margins, hedging, geopolitical risk and wider market pressure.
Exxon shares dipped around 1% Friday, as did Chevron shares, and Exxon CEO Darren Woods suggested there might be “more to come” on price rises connected to the Iran conflict, according to a Fortune story.
Which leads to a divided arrangement.
Oil producers might gain if oil prices hold over $100 for an extended length of time. But if prices grow too fast, there is a serious risk of demand destruction.
Goldman Sachs has warned that global oil demand in April might be much lower than in February, with the weakness mostly in jet fuel and petrochemical feedstocks, CNBC reported.
More Oil and Gas:
- Early Chevron stock investors now earn 12.1% dividend yield
- Chevron, Shell ink more surprising Venezuela deals
- AAA gas prices reveal a new trend for Americans
Related: OPEC shake-up throws oil prices major curveball
Energy-stock takeaways for investors
- Exxon and Chevron benefit from elevated crude, but volatility can pressure shares.
- USO gives more direct oil-price exposure, but futures-based funds can be volatile.
- XLE offers broader energy-sector exposure through large oil and gas holdings.
- Refiners may face margin pressure if crude costs rise faster than fuel demand.
- Oil-service stocks could benefit if producers increase spending, but that may take time.
Oil’s next move could decide the energy trade
Right now, oil equities have a more apparent catalyst than they had earlier this year.
If oil prices continue to remain robust, corporations such as Exxon and Chevron may be able to keep making money from higher prices, disciplined output and investor appetite for cash-producing enterprises.
But this is not a simple “oil up, stocks up” tale.
The market is also taking into account inflation risk, decreased gasoline demand, tanker interruptions and the potential for geopolitical headlines to flip rapidly.
That gives the present arrangement force but also brittleness.
The energy trade wasn’t over when oil fell back from $126. It made it harder.
The message to investors bluntly states that energy equities may have further to go, but the easy part of the surge is finished.
Related: Goldman Sachs revamps oil price forecast on supply squeeze
