Second in a series

Lisa Featherngill spent more than 40 years in wealth management and regularly advised business owners about the importance of having something to retire to, not just something to retire from. But when an acquisition eliminated her own position, she discovered how difficult it could be to follow that advice. 

What began with a celebration became a period of anxiety, unfinished business and questions about professional identity. Six months later, she was still deciding how much of her former working life she wanted to keep. Her experience offers lessons for anyone preparing to retire, particularly those whose departure comes sooner than expected. Below is a transcript of my interview with Featherngill

Why retirement brought an unexpected wave of panic

Bob Powell: You were looking forward to retirement, and you knew your last day was coming. But something unexpected happened after you left. What surprised you most?

Lisa Featherngill: It was really kind of calm on the last day. I knew it was coming. I knew my position was going to be eliminated because I was going through an acquisition and there was duplication.

I found out about the middle of January that I was going to be in the first wave of displacements on Feb. 1.

I was actually pretty excited because I had wanted to retire by the end of 2026.

It created a beautiful path for me. I came home, and my husband and I toasted.

The next day, I was feeling really good. And then I woke up about 2 o’clock in the morning to panic. Panic followed by guilt.

All I could think about was what I needed to do in the next two weeks to get everything wrapped up.

Powell: What was causing that panic?

Featherngill: February was the time we made decisions around bonuses and salary increases. I knew I wasn’t going to be there.

In fact, really all of our wealth management leadership team was being displaced. I was concerned about my people and who was going to speak up for them.

That kept me up a lot of nights. I spent a lot of time making sure I had talked to enough people who could have a voice in those decisions.

I woke up about two o’clock in the morning to panic. Panic followed by guilt.

What she hadn’t anticipated before leaving work

Powell: Beyond your responsibilities to your employees, what else did you discover you needed to take care of?

Featherngill: Like a lot of people, my personal calendar was on my work calendar. There was a lot of personal stuff on my computer, and I had to figure out what I could take without it being considered proprietary information.

So I was back and forth with HR.

There was just a lot that I had not anticipated, even though I kind of knew this was coming.

It wasn’t real until right before the end.

Powell: People approaching retirement sometimes say that knowing it’s coming isn’t the same as being ready for it. By the time your last day arrived, did you feel ready?

Featherngill: I felt like I was ready. I had spent those last two weeks getting everything checked off my list. That was my main focus.

But ironically, on my last day, we were in a snowstorm, so the office was closed.

I had to turn in my badge and my computer through UPS or something like that.

It was a little anticlimactic, but that was my last day.

Malte Mueller / Getty Images

Why leaving work meant questioning her identity

Powell: Was there any sadness associated with leaving?

Featherngill: When I look back on it, part of me might have been in denial, and maybe still is a little bit, because there’s a lot of identity associated with work.

I always advised clients who were business owners, when they were going to retire or sell their business, that they really needed something to go to because they needed a new identity.

Well, it’s the same thing for somebody who’s been in an industry or a business for a long period of time.

There’s so much identity wrapped up in your work. And I just wasn’t even thinking about changing my identity.

I thought I’d go three months, and then I’d be picking up some part-time work or project work.

People kept telling me, no, give it six months.

Now it’s been over six months, and I’m still not ready to let go.

Powell: You had spent years advising others about this very issue. Did you find yourself continuing to follow what was happening at your former workplace?

Featherngill: I probably had a few too many conversations with people I left behind to find out what was going on.

How she created a new professional identity

Powell: You wrote a LinkedIn post about your new identity and even gave yourself a new title. Tell us about that.

Featherngill: Part of this was not letting go of my identity.

I wanted to put something on LinkedIn on my final day, thanking people who had helped me along the way and letting people know I was changing careers.

ChatGPT helped me create a really nice post.

But the next week, I thought, I can’t have my former employer’s name up there on my profile. I need to change it.

Then I thought, what am I going to change it to? I don’t know what to call myself.

So I went back to ChatGPT, and it said, “Call yourself semi-retired by design.”

And that is what my title is now.

Powell: And you haven’t completely closed the door on working again?

Featherngill: No. Along the lines of not being ready to give up my identity and involvement in the industry, I set up an LLC for any work I might take on.

I had talked to some different organizations about consulting work.

Wealth by Design is the name of my LLC.

Why one small decision took four weeks

Powell: We’ve talked about your last day. But in the weeks and months since, what has surprised you?

Featherngill: I’ve been on an industry award panel for about the last 10 or 12 years.

In the middle of July, they asked me if I would be willing to sign up again for the coming year.

It took me four weeks to make a decision.

One part of me was saying, I’m not in the industry anymore. Maybe I shouldn’t be part of that panel.

Another part of me was saying, yeah, but if I give it up, then I’m really out of the industry.

I went back and forth.

Finally, I landed on the fact that it’s not a huge time commitment. I really like reviewing the nominations and seeing what’s going on.

I feel like I’ve got more than 40 years in the industry. I can add some value to the award panel.

And I really like the people involved, so I decided to stay involved.

Powell: You don’t strike me as someone who normally takes four weeks to make a decision. What made this one so difficult?

Featherngill: There were some sleepless nights on that one, too.

It’s identity. I think a lot of it is me struggling with my identity and struggling with where I want to go with my retirement.

Do I want to continue doing additional work?

I feel like this keeps the door open for me and keeps that decision open.

But I’m six months in, and it’s still not easy.

Powell: Did you make a spreadsheet listing the pros and cons?

Featherngill: I’m sure I had a mental spreadsheet because I was waking up in the morning thinking about the pros and cons.

What she would do differently before retiring

Powell: For people anticipating their own last day, what advice would you give them? Is there a checklist they should be working through?

Featherngill: Don’t do what I did. Don’t wait until the last two weeks to think about who and what might be impacted by your leaving.

Who are the people? Are they people who work for you? Are they your clients? Are they your partners?

Who might be impacted, and how?

Have a plan for how to address that upfront, before you leave.

I wish I had started that maybe four, five or six weeks before I left.

I probably would have had more sleep the last two weeks before my last day.

Powell: Some people know their retirement date well in advance. Others may have only two or three weeks’ notice because their position has been eliminated. Does that change how they should approach the transition?

Featherngill: That’s right. Once you get that notice, it’s kind of easy to switch gears and say, OK, I’m not taking on more work right now.

Let me finish up what I’ve got and figure out the plan for dealing with all these other things.

What comes after the last day

Powell: We’ve discussed your final day and the unexpected challenges that followed. In a future episode, we’ll talk about your first Monday in retirement. What was that experience like?

Featherngill: That was very hard for me.

Related: She advised clients on retirement for 40 years. Then her own retirement changed her thinking.