Retailers have never had more ways to track customer experience — surveys, loyalty apps, even smiley-face kiosks near the exit.
And yet, getting it right still feels harder than ever.
A new report from HappyOrNot offers a rare glimpse into what actually moves the needle for shoppers.
Related: Customer loyalty tested: the call to boycott Alo Yoga
The findings suggest that while big factors like price, service, and product selection still matter, small overlooked details could have an outsized impact.
One surprising insight? Timing plays a key role in customer satisfaction. But most retailers aren’t fully capitalizing on it.
Timing could be the hidden key to unlocking better customer experiences.
Image source: Getty Images
Customers love shopping at this time of day
HappyOrNot analyzed over 57 million customer interactions across retail stores worldwide. They found that customer satisfaction peaks early in the day, specifically between 7 and 8 a.m. — a time when many stores aren’t even open.
In fact, satisfaction scores during these morning hours were 14% higher than those recorded after 6 p.m.
That’s a major gap, suggesting that when stores fail to engage the early crowd, they could be missing out on prime opportunities to build loyalty.
Related: TikTok made this beloved beverage trendy, and supply can’t keep up
The report also found that Tuesdays and Wednesdays delivered the highest average customer satisfaction scores across the week. Meanwhile, weekends showed a 7% decrease in satisfaction, as stores became busier and shopping environments became more stressful.
Timing, both by day and by hour, seems to play a bigger role than most retailers might expect.
What this data means for retailers
Retailers chasing loyalty aren’t just competing on price or branding anymore. They’re competing on micro-moments — the tiny emotional wins that leave customers feeling seen and cared for.
Opening earlier may not be realistic for every business. But designing better early-day experiences, optimizing staffing, and doubling down on store cleanliness could turn small wins into major loyalty drivers.
In a world flooded with choice, the best ways to stand out might go beyond flash sales or loyalty programs.
They might involve showing up at the right moment — something as simple as opening the doors earlier and being ready when shoppers are.
Related: Veteran fund manager unveils eye-popping S&P 500 forecast
