American workers trying to juggle credit card balances, car payments and student loans alongside retirement savings face sharply conflicting advice from two of personal finance’s biggest voices — just as the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) expands how much workers can shelter in workplace plans.
On Nov. 12, 2026, the IRS announced higher contribution limits for workplace retirement accounts in 2027, giving workers a larger tax-advantaged window to build long-term savings.
“The annual contribution limit for employees who participate in 401(k), 403(b), governmental 457 plans, and the federal government’s Thrift Savings Plan is increased to $25,500, up from $24,500 for 2026,” wrote the IRS.
While those higher caps create new opportunities for savers, personal finance author Dave Ramsey and investment giant Fidelity Investments offer directly opposing blueprints on whether workers with non-mortgage debt should contribute to a 401(k) at all — even when an employer is offering a matching contribution.
Dave Ramsey says to pause 401(k) contributions — even the match
In Ramsey Solutions’ seven-stage financial framework, paying off all non-mortgage debt comes strictly before retirement investing. Under the second phase of Ramsey’s recommended approach, borrowers list debts from smallest balance to largest using the debt snowball method and stop investing until every non-mortgage balance is cleared.
“Pay off all non-mortgage debt before you save or invest for the future,” wrote Ramsey Solutions. “If you pay off debt first, it can leave you with significantly more wealth by retirement than if you invest while you’re still making debt payments.”
Ramsey’s guidance holds firm even when an employer offers a 401(k) match, arguing that splitting focus slows progress on both fronts.
“Once you’re no longer sending payments to a lender every month, you can put far more of your income toward building wealth,” Ramsey Solutions continued. “Because when you focus your energy on one goal at a time (instead of trying to do too many things at once), you make more progress.”
Ramsey Solutions argues that trying to invest while paying double-digit interest on consumer debt drains money out the bottom faster than market gains can build it up, and stresses that halting retirement savings — including any employer match — is a temporary move meant to keep all energy focused on wiping out debt quickly.
“No. Pause all investing, even the match,” Ramsey Solutions wrote in its frequently asked questions on paying off non-mortgage debt. “Once you’re debt-free with a full emergency fund, you’ll more than make up for the time off.”

Shutterstock
Fidelity warns against leaving ‘free money’ on the table
Fidelity Investments takes the opposite approach, placing an employer 401(k) match ahead of paying off credit cards, student loans and auto debt.
In its step-by-step debt and savings roadmap, Fidelity instructs workers to first make minimum debt payments, use pre-tax health accounts if eligible and build a $1,000 starter cash buffer before capturing their full workplace match.
“Your employer’s match is essentially ‘free money,’ so not taking advantage of it is a bit like leaving money on the table,” wrote Fidelity.
For savers age 50 and older, pausing workplace contributions also means sidelining expanded catch-up room that the IRS increased for the 2027 tax year.
“The catch-up contribution limit that generally applies for employees aged 50 and over who participate in most 401(k), 403(b), governmental 457 plans, and the federal government’s Thrift Savings Plan is increased to $8,500, up from $8,000 for 2026,” noted the IRS.
Fidelity advises checking employer vesting schedules before banking on matching funds, then moving aggressively against credit card balances only after capturing the full match.
“Paying down any credit card debt and fully funding your emergency savings should generally be your next moves, before you move on to other investing or debt goals,” Fidelity explained.
Fidelity’s ‘rule of 6%’ vs. Ramsey’s debt snowball
Once high-interest credit cards are eliminated and emergency savings are funded, Fidelity and Ramsey diverge again on how to handle remaining installment debt such as student loans or car notes.
Rather than halting all investing until every loan hits zero, Fidelity measures debt interest rates against expected investment returns using its “rule of 6%.”
“For many people, it generally makes sense to first pay down any debt with an interest rate of 6% or greater,” wrote Fidelity.
If a borrower’s remaining debt carries an interest rate below 6%, Fidelity suggests putting unmatched retirement dollars to work in a tax-advantaged account like a 401(k) or IRA.
“If the interest rate on your debt is less than 6% (and again, based on our set of assumptions), it likely makes more sense to invest those extra dollars instead,” Fidelity added.
More Retirement:
- Annuities can be a retirement safety net to prevent outliving savings
- Vanguard flags a retirement fear built into 401(k) plans
- Suze Orman has a serious retirement warning for 2027
Meanwhile, the IRS emphasized that its 2027 retirement adjustments — alongside broader tax changes — are designed to help households preserve more of their earnings as they weigh those competing financial priorities.
“Along with the Working Families Tax Cuts, this increase in the pension limitations will help American families keep more of their hard-earned income,” said IRS Chief Executive Officer Frank J. Bisignano in the IRS announcement.
For workers caught between both camps, the decision comes down to math versus behavior.
So the choice is between locking in immediate employer-matched returns and tax-deferred compounding under Fidelity’s framework, or eliminating every non-mortgage payment first under Ramsey’s playbook.
Related: Dave Ramsey issues sobering outlook on Social Security, 401(k)s, IRAs