Every November, Wall Street offers stock market investors the same comforting promise. No matter how rocky autumn gets, the year-end holiday rally could potentially rescue your portfolio.
Right now, everyday investors desperately want to hold on to that belief. On Thursday, November 19, the S&P 500 dropped 147 points, or 2%, to close at 7,175, locking in its fourth straight losing session as more than 90% of index stocks finished red and the Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) jumped 15.8% to 28.44.
Between Federal Reserve rate-hike jitters, 10-year Treasury yields hovering above 5%, and widespread smart-money selling linked to Anthropic’s record $81.3 billion IPO, stocks look remarkably fragile.
That makes a fresh seasonal study from Goldman Sachs’ FICC and Equities desk perhaps a lot more urgent. Though history still favors a late-December bounce, Goldman’s data delivers a sobering verdict.
When market fear runs this hot heading into Thanksgiving, the famous year-end rally loses nearly half its punch.
What Goldman Sachs’ holiday data really says
In a research note cited by Seeking Alpha, Goldman Sachs unpacked decades of S&P 500 holiday seasonality and showed that year-end gains almost never arrive smoothly. Historically, the index rises about 2.4% from mid-November through December 31, following a distinct four-phase roller coaster.
More Wall Street:
- Arista Networks stock gets fresh backing from Jim Cramer and Wall Street
- Oracle stock sinks as Wall Street confronts a $20 billion AI problem
- Wall Street just got a candid look at who is winning the AI race
There’s typically a mid-November dip, a Thanksgiving ramp-up (rising roughly 1.1% into early December), an early-December stall that surrenders about two-thirds of those gains, and a late-December rally.
That final stretch is arguably Wall Street’s most reliable tailwind. Since 1990, the S&P 500 has climbed between December 15 and year-end in 27 of 36 years (75% of the time).
Over the 17 years since 1990, when the VIX started mid-November at 18 or higher, the S&P 500’s average year-end gain shrank by almost half to just 1.34%, rising in only 59% of those years while suffering a median drawdown of 3%.
On the day the report arrived, the VIX sat at 22.82, before surging to 28.44 by the close amid hawkish Fed minutes and Governor Christopher Waller’s call for a potential rate “shock.” Perhaps the silver lining is that the fear itself surprisingly cools off, with the VIX dropping by year-end in 14 of those 17 high-volatility years.

Where major banks see the S&P 500 in 2027, and the warning they all share
Looking beyond December’s turbulence, however, major Wall Street banks are remarkably unified on 2027.
Three heavyweights in Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley, and Barclays have all set 2027 S&P 500 targets at 8,700 (implying 21.3% upside from Thursday’s close), while UBS equity strategists reaffirmed an even higher 8,900 call (+24%) even as the bank turned neutral on the U.S. stock market, as reported by Seeking Alpha.
Major bank outlooks underscore a fundamental handoff, where pricing multiples might no longer be able to carry the market. J.P. Morgan now projects three consecutive quarter-point Fed rate hikes across December, January, and March, and Goldman forecasts hikes in December and March, Reuters reported.
As a consequence, corporate profits need to do all the heavy lifting, even as earnings growth cools from 2026’s blistering pace. Goldman expects U.S. earnings growth to slow from 36% to 11% in 2027; Morgan Stanley chief strategist Mike Wilson models 14% EPS growth to $420, while noting that stocks are already testing his 7,100–7,300 support zone.
“We expect equities to generate positive returns, albeit with higher volatility than in recent years,” Goldman Sachs Chief Global Equity Strategist Peter Oppenheimer wrote in a November 16 outlook. “We expect investors to seek companies that can sustain growth as it becomes more scarce.”
How everyday investors should play the holiday roller coaster
For investors, Goldman’s seasonal warning offers some pertinent takeaways.
Firstly, it’s daft to expect a painless Thanksgiving melt-up. With the VIX above 28 and the Fed tightening, another 3% pullback or early-December stall aligns with history’s script before late-December relief arrives.
Secondly, upgrade portfolio quality instead of simply chasing crowded AI multiples. For perspective, Bank of America’s November Fund Manager Survey, reported by Bloomberg, showed institutional pros slashed tech overweight to the greatest extent since 2006, while Barclays bumped healthcare and high-quality stocks to positive.
Additionally, with AI stocks under pressure, Jim Cramer’s restaurant picks make a case for being selective instead of simply rotating out of tech. He passed on Shake Shack at about 60 times earnings and pointed instead to Brinker and Texas Roadhouse, where lower beef costs could help strengthen margins.
Finally, it’s imperative to keep cash ready to deploy patiently into mid-December dips, letting Wall Street’s valuation reset from over 23 times forward earnings down to roughly 18 times forward earnings, working in your favor heading into 2027.
Related: Billionaire Stanley Druckenmiller issues blunt warning on stocks and Fed rate hikes