Fewer shoppers are walking into Home Depot these days, but the ones who do are spending more per trip.

The average ticket rose 3% in the third quarter while customer transactions slipped, according to the company’s earnings release.

That split matters more now, because the man who has watched it as CFO since 2019 is about to run the company.

Home Depot said on Tuesday that Richard McPhail will become CEO on Nov. 23, replacing Ted Decker, according to a company announcement.

Also read: Home Depot brings back viral Christmas tree with major holiday upgrade

Shares closed down about 2.5% on Tuesday, according to StockAnalysis data. That came even though McPhail said third-quarter results “exceeded our expectations.” The reaction looks tied less to the man than to the outlook he inherits.

The board turned a stopgap into the permanent plan

McPhail had a head start. Decker went on medical leave in August, Reuters reported. A Home Depot filing shows that McPhail and Ann-Marie Campbell then ran an interim office of the CEO, with McPhail as interim principal executive officer.

That setup was in place for the rest of the third quarter, which ended Nov. 1. The interim team effectively got a three-month tryout, and the board has now largely made it permanent.

The new lineup mirrors the temporary one. McPhail becomes CEO, and Campbell becomes president and chief operating officer, adding supply chain and online to her job, the company said. Jordan Broggi, a 13-year veteran, takes over as CFO.

Decker returned from leave on Nov. 13 and will step down as CEO while staying on as board chair, according to the filing. Home Depot gave no reason for the timing beyond what independent lead director Greg Brenneman called “ongoing, active succession planning.”

The filing says Decker remains chair “to support the leadership transition,” and his pay suggests real involvement. His fiscal 2027 equity target as chair is $12.8 million, above the $11.5 million target set for McPhail as CEO, according to the filing.

Home Depot named CFO Richard McPhail its next CEO effective Nov. 23, with Ted Decker stepping down as CEO but staying on as board chair.

Bloomberg / Getty Images

Sales are rising faster than the profit behind them

The tryout came with a catch. Home Depot now expects full-year sales growth at the high end of its earlier range, but its adjusted operating margin is near the low end of its prior target, Reuters reported.

Put simply, the company is selling more while keeping a little less of each dollar. Total sales should grow about 4.5% this fiscal year, according to the earnings release.

Comparable sales, which track the existing business, should rise only about 1.4%, the release says.

Acquired businesses help explain that gap, and McPhail ran point on them. As CFO, he oversaw the purchases of HD Supply, SRS Distribution, and GMS, the company said. Those deals pushed Home Depot deeper into selling to professional contractors.

That is the twist in this handoff. The executive who bought much of Home Depot’s recent growth now has to show it pays.

Analysts at Zacks Investment Management and CFRA said new CEOs often step up investment early, which could pressure near-term margins, according to Reuters.

A finance chief may be slower than most to spend freely, but he will also be judged hardest if margins keep slipping.

Most analysts trimmed targets but kept their ratings

Home Depot calls itself the world’s largest home improvement retailer, and investors often treat its stock as a bet on the U.S. housing market. It also pays a dividend yielding about 2.8%, according to StockAnalysis, which keeps it on income investors’ radar.

The shares had already climbed about 25% from their October low heading into the report, based on StockAnalysis price data. A run like that leaves little room for a quarter that is merely good.

Even so, the stock sits well below its all-time high of $439.37, reached in November 2024, according to StockAnalysis. The site’s chart begins in 1983, and the all-time low sits in those early years.

More Retail:

Wall Street still leans positive. Of the 36 analysts tracked by StockAnalysis, 22 rate Home Depot a Buy or a Strong Buy, and 14 rate it a Hold. Their average price target is $376.63, the site shows.

Most target changes posted Wednesday were cuts. Evercore ISI, J.P. Morgan and Mizuho kept Buy ratings but lowered their targets, while RBC Capital trimmed its target and stayed at Hold, StockAnalysis data show.

DA Davidson and Truist nudged their targets higher, StockAnalysis’ news feed shows. On balance, analysts still seem to like the business while expecting a bit less profit from each sale.

The real test arrives with next year’s outlook

Home Depot skipped the outsider and the turnaround specialist. It promoted one of the architects of its contractor strategy, which tells investors the playbook is staying put.

That playbook leans on a trend Reuters described: Pro demand has held up better than do-it-yourself spending, while high borrowing costs weigh on bigger home projects. Home Depot is betting contractors can carry it until the housing market thaws.

McPhail’s first annual outlook as CEO will show whether that bet can lift profits as well as sales. If margins steady, Tuesday’s dip will look like a pause. If they keep slipping, investors will learn what a numbers man can and cannot fix.

More Stocks News