Most people have told a boss or a contractor some version of “I underestimated this.” The admission buys a little trust. It also resets the clock, because the fix rarely arrives on schedule.
Nike (NKE) is living inside that reset. On its earnings call on Oct. 1, Morgan Stanley analyst Alex Straton asked CEO Elliott Hill what he had underappreciated about the trouble in Jordan, China, and Sportswear.
Hill gave a rare, plain answer. “I probably did underappreciate breaking it down into segments focused on a distinct consumer,” he said, according to Nike’s official transcript.
About seven weeks later, Straton’s team has turned the same question on investors. In a Nov. 18 note shared with TheStreet, Morgan Stanley argued that Nike’s stock still underappreciates how deep and how long the company’s reset will run.
The firm kept its Underweight rating and $25 price target, implying about 30% downside when the note came out.
Also read: Nike just put a date on its comeback after a 13-year stock low
Valuation is the heart of that warning. Nike shares traded at about 34 times the earnings Morgan Stanley expects in fiscal 2028, according to the note. That is a price for a company about to grow, not one still shrinking.
Shareholders have already paid for earlier delays. Nike’s market value and earnings have more than halved since Hill returned two years ago, according to Reuters.
Hill’s miss was in the sneakers people know best
Sportswear is Nike’s lifestyle business: the Dunks casual sneakers and everyday clothes worn far from any gym. It made up just under half of Nike’s revenue last quarter.
That business fell at a low double-digit rate. Part of the drop was planned. Nike cut Dunk revenue by nearly 50% as it pulled back on the franchise.
Hill’s fix is to split Sportswear into smaller groups of shoppers. However, Morgan Stanley says the investor day left out a harder answer: where Sportswear may need to shrink further, and how Nike will handle businesses it oversupplied in recent years.

Morgan Stanley believes the shrinking isn’t finished
Nike expects Sportswear, Jordan, and Converse together to add about $1 billion in revenue by fiscal 2031, according to a press release it filed with the SEC.
Morgan Stanley disagrees. Its earlier work suggests Nike Sportswear and Jordan may each need to end up about 25% smaller than in fiscal 2026, the note said.
By fiscal 2031, the views sit far apart:
- Sales land near $40 billion in Morgan Stanley’s view, versus the roughly $47 billion to $48 billion Nike’s targets imply.
- Operating margin settles around 9.5%, the firm estimates, short of Nike’s 12% to 14% goal.
- Earnings per share reach about $2 in Morgan Stanley’s model, against management’s $3.00 to $3.50.
Nike’s finish line looks a lot like its starting line
The most overlooked number may be Nike’s own. The note puts fiscal 2026 revenue at about $46.4 billion.
The sales level Nike’s 2031 plan implies sits only slightly above that. In other words, five years of rebuilding mostly returns Nike to where it already stood. Morgan Stanley’s $40 billion estimate would leave the company about 14% smaller than in fiscal 2026.
The last investor day offers a contrast. In 2017, Nike told investors to expect earnings per share growth in the mid-teens over five years, and the shares jumped, CNBC reported.
This time, management warned that earnings would slip again in fiscal 2028 before recovering, the note said.
More Nike:
- Nike is purposely selling fewer shoes as its shares keep falling
- Nike CEO admits blind spot as Jordan and Dunk sales shrink
- Nike has a long road ahead to win customers back
Patience is now the price of owning Nike
As a result, Morgan Stanley cut its fiscal 2028 earnings estimate to $1.04 a share from $1.35. The firm may not turn more positive before late 2027 or early 2028.
Fiscal 2029 is when everything has to work at once. Morgan Stanley says that year needs better Sportswear, steadier Jordan and China results, and a return to sales and profit growth.
RBC Capital Markets analyst Piral Dadhania put it plainly to Reuters in October: “Things are going to get worse before they get better.”
Even Morgan Stanley’s best case now depends on Nike hitting its own plan. The firm raised its bull case to $47 from $38, roughly in line with management’s targets. Yet options pricing implied only about a 16% chance the stock tops $47 within a year, the note said.
Investors may also see less just as they need more. Nike will report under three broader regions from fiscal 2028, which Morgan Stanley warns could blur China’s results.
This is bigger than one sneaker company. When a market fragments, the biggest brand can lose the growth and margins that once justified a premium valuation. Hill has already admitted what he underestimated.
The next test is whether investors will make the same admission about what a smaller Nike is worth.