When Hershey (HSY) debuted its giant Reese’s Pie before Thanksgiving in 2021, shoppers bought all 3,000 pies in less than two hours. The candy maker is bringing it back for Thanksgiving this year, with an online sale Monday, Nov. 16, and reports that the pie has already turned up at warehouse clubs.
The pie is really one giant Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup. It measures 9 inches across and weighs more than 3 pounds, with a ridged milk chocolate shell in place of a baked crust.
Hershey says it’s bringing the limited-edition pie back in response to fan demand. It will cost $49.99 online this year, up $5 from its debut price. Hershey will limit shoppers to two pies per order and hasn’t shared how many will be available online. If you’re counting on the pie for Thanksgiving dessert, look for a delivery estimate when you order.
Some warehouse club shoppers got an early look at the pie this fall. Sightings at Costco and BJ’s Wholesale Club date back to October, weeks before Hershey’s online sale. Hershey says select clubs have carried it in limited quantities, with availability varying by location.
A third-party inventory tracker listed the pie at $39.99 at Costco on Friday, $10 less than Hershey plans to charge online.
Also Read: Amazon Prime swaps Grubhub for Uber Eats in major perk shake-up
When can you buy the Reese’s Pie online?
The pie goes on sale at Hershey’s online shop at 9 a.m. ET Monday, Nov. 16. That’s 8 a.m. CT, 7 a.m. MT, and 6 a.m. PT. The pies will be sold first come, first served while supplies last.
The product page has a waitlist for shoppers who want a reminder before the sale. Everyone who signs up still has to place an order once the sale opens. Hershey told TheStreet it had no delivery timing details to share for Monday’s launch.

Hershey
Where has the Reese’s Pie been spotted in stores?
Food blogger Markie Devo reported sightings at Costco and BJ’s Wholesale Club on Oct. 15 and credited fellow food account @jerseyfoodnfinds with the first in-store find. Food & Wine cited the sightings in its coverage.
A company representative couldn’t confirm to TheStreet which chains or locations received the pie.
More Retail:
- Struggling home goods chain closing more stores
- Verizon makes changes to be more like T-Mobile used to be
- Home Depot drops generous offers as customers grow harder to win
Warehouse Runner, which tracks Costco inventory and prices, listed the 52-ounce Reese’s Pie for $39.99 on Nov. 13. Of the 73 warehouses the tracker had data for, 58 showed the pie in stock, 13 showed low stock, and two were out.
Costco shoppers can look up item No. 2070751 in the Costco app or call their local warehouse to check current availability and pricing before making a trip.
How should you store and serve the Reese’s Pie?
If you get one before Thanksgiving, Hershey recommends storing it in a cool, dry place at room temperature, away from heat and direct sunlight. If you’ve already put it in the fridge, let it reach room temperature before slicing.
Wondering how many people a giant peanut butter cup can feed? The box for the original pie suggested cutting it into 48 slices, TheStreet reported in 2021.
Related: Starbucks and Panera add a surprise to the holiday treasure hunt