Target Chief Merchandising Officer Cara Sylvester has made it clear that while the company has posted some strong results, its turnaround has just begun.
She also shared her vision for what a visit to the chain’s brick-and-mortar stores should deliver to customers.
“Target has the ability to turn an ordinary shopping trip into something special. Guests come to us for what they need, but they also expect to discover something new, whether that’s an emerging beauty brand, a great design collaboration, or a cultural moment they can’t find anywhere else,” she said during the retailer’s third-quarter earnings call.
That’s a bold vision, and maybe a little risky, given that embracing “cultural moments” contributed to Target’s past struggles, but while celebrating the chain’s success, Sylvester also shared its biggest failures.

Shutterstock
Target has two clear apparel problems
Sylvester noted that the company has made strides in its home collection, did well with back-to-school, and has seen strong gains across multiple areas. She was also blunt about what isn’t working.
“In apparel, our challenges are more significant. So I want to spend a minute on where we’re seeing progress and where we’ve fallen short. While overall apparel performance remains below our expectations, we’re seeing strength across several businesses, including men’s, kids, women’s swim, and young contemporary, all of which are growing versus last year,” she said.
The problems, she noted, are very specific.
“Our underperformance really comes down to 2 categories: women’s fashion and shoes, both of which have lagged broader trends,” she added.
Sylvester accepted the blame for those shortcomings.
“I want to be direct about why. In women’s fashion, we made the assortment and value proposition too complex. We lost focus on some of the foundational pieces our guests count on, and we weren’t consistent enough on fit, fabric, and quality,” she shared.

TheStreet
Target making more changes
Sylvester shared Target’s plans to fix its women’s apparel and shoe lines.
“We’re making meaningful changes. We’ve made leadership changes in these categories. We’re getting back to the fundamentals, working more closely with vendors and seeking more direct guest feedback. We’re reducing style counts by approximately 20% to sharpen our point of view and simplify the assortment,” she added.
RTM Nexus CEO Dominick Miserandino sees a major flaw in Target’s women’s apparel business.
“Target has always been great at selling women’s clothing they didn’t necessarily leave the house intending to buy. You go in for shampoo, paper towels, and maybe something for dinner, and suddenly you’re trying on a sweater. But there’s a difference between buying clothes at Target and going to Target specifically to shop for clothes. I think that’s where the company is struggling,” he told TheStreet.
Retail expert and analyst Maurie Backman thinks that Target simply needs better merchandise on its shelves.
“Target used to be a place for women’s clothing. Now, not so much. The prices aren’t particularly competitive, and the selection isn’t as good as it used to be,” she told TheStreet.
She’s hopeful, however, that the chain should be able to fix these categories.
“That said, Target is overhauling a lot of its inventory as part of its turnaround plan, so I wouldn’t write it off as a fashion destination. I just probably wouldn’t go there to buy clothing right now,” she added.
Related: Target gives shoppers something Walmart and Kroger can’t