United Airlines has garnered a reputation for being America’s most ‘tech-forward’ airline, but we know that it’s not afraid to make a change that nobody likes.

This year, they’ve made big changes to their loyalty program and miles earnings on flights, while following their primary competitor down the dark path of unbundling and complicating fares.

But they found one more way to antagonize certain tech-minded customers as the year draws to a close. Last week, the carrier updated its Contract of Carriage to ban “automated” tools such as AI bots from booking flights on behalf of users, citing a need to protect customer data and accounts.

The recent changes come amid a slew of high-profile outages and cybersecurity incidents, which have affected everything from digital services to air traffic control. At the same time, a growing number of consumers are delegating tasks to AI that they don’t want to do themselves.

Why is United banning AI?

In a statement, United said that, “Sharing account credentials with personal, third-party, AI assistants can expose sensitive information, and actions taken by these tools may result in unintended purchases, account charges, or use of MileagePlus miles.”

The airline cited that many businesses in the “banking and retail industries have taken similar actions regarding AI agents,” in recent weeks, with the airline encouraging firms to consider similar measures to “preserve the data and security of their customers and strengthen safety.”

In other words, United wants to protect users from themselves — and maybe they need that. An Axios scoop from late October indicated that U.S. banks have detected “unauthorized third-party AI agents operating inside customer accounts, with some agents attempting to take actions that appear to be independent of user instructions.” A growing number of banks are even changing their terms and conditions to disclaim responsibility for customers’ AI mistakes.

Separately, United cited that booking with “automated AI actions” could potentially run aground of Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) and Department of Transportation (DoT) regulations, since certain attestations are required to book and check in for flights.

United’s changes mean that those found violating these new rules, whether to book a flight, choose seats, or reschedule a flight under less ideal conditions, could see their flights cancelled.

As a “prohibited ticketing practice”, booking with these methods could also give the airline the option to confiscate your frequent flyer miles or refuse to let you board.

United joins the AI safetyist

United has positioned itself as America’s most ‘tech-forward’ airline by making massive investments in customers’ digital experience. They now boast one of the best airline apps in the industry, boast seat-back screens, and are deploying high-speed SpaceX Starlink Wi-Fi across its fleet.

However, there’s an argument that this move is decisively ‘tech-backwards’, even if it is presented as a matter of compliance and safety. I wouldn’t personally delegate any meaningful financial task to AI right now, certainly not without oversight.

However, regardless of how well-intentioned the statement is, I am doubtful of United’s reasoning. The famously ‘follow the leader’ U.S. airline industry has not followed suit with bans of their own. In fact, the CEO of their primary competition, Delta, says that it’s “too early” to rule out customer use of AI.

Further, I wonder how much of their customer base really is using AI to book travel or flights. I doubt there is a large constituency handing off important tasks to AI without intervention at this stage. I am even bigger doubter that most United customers have even heard of “AI agents.”

You also have to wonder what kind of “data” that United is utilizing to monitor automated or agentic traffic and stop those bookings. Sure, they can block a few IP addresses from big AI platforms, but is it realistic to stop all automated traffic?

And if what AI heads are right about the stratospheric growth of the industry, is that a realistic course of action if AI agent usage continues to grow?

AI for me, not for thee

However well-intentioned United’s move is, I am doubtful of their reasons. I argue that today’s adopters of AI tools should understand, accept, and assume the risks of using it for important tasks. If businesses want to reach this (so far) modest market, they can introduce solutions which improve safety.

That said, a nanny state isn’t the answer, and it isn’t a pragmatic solution. Candidly, I come away from United’s recent changes with a greater reluctance about United, the amount of data they’re collecting, and their supposed ‘good intentions’ with travelers.

Thus far, I’ve been pretty charitable to United’s “safety” and “compliance” claims, but truthfully, I think this is more about information asymmetry. It’s about making sure that customers don’t have a new tool to retaliate against the uncompetitive airline industry and its tactics.

While United is banning AI bots, we know that it and other industry peers are using all sorts of AI and machine learning to get customers to pay more — and they’re not being subtle about it either.

The Federal Trade Commission is investigating United and other carriers for how they use AI and personal data to charge customers different fares through dynamic “surveillance” pricing. The collection, processing, and use of large swaths of customer data isn’t just used to price customers, but for targeted advertising, too.

And while they’re saying customers can’t use AI agents to constantly monitor fares, book affordable fares, and rebook cancelled or delayed flights, they’re embracing the use of AI systems to supplant the use of customer service and critical staff.

They suspect their use of AI constitutes responsible use, but yours is not. Investors call what they’re doing “good business”, but when you do it, your flights get cancelled and they can take away rewards points that you earned (that you paid for!)

I think that lays the reality of this situation plain. No, I don’t use AI to book my flights, but I know a hypocrite when I see one.