Walmart wants customers to shell out $30 for a mystery box that it promises will contain $139 worth of beauty products.
It’s a bold bet that consumers, who have been more careful with their cash than in previous years, will want to buy something without knowing exactly what it is.
For about a year, I was gifted a subscription to a mystery box.
Every quarter it showed up, and I’d open it hoping that something inside would be useful. In most cases, there were a number of things in the box, and one or two of them would be useful.
One contained a car vacuum, while others had bar accessories that I have rarely used, but probably should have available.
Buying a box without knowing what’s in it, even if you know the brand and the category, adds a level of gambling to shopping.
Walmart and its new partner, FabFitFun, will bring the “brand’s signature discovery experience beyond its membership platform and directly to Walmart shoppers for the first time,” according to a press release.
The limited-edition FabFitFun Holiday Mystery Beauty Box is available at approximately 3,000 Walmart locations across the U.S. for $30, featuring four full-size beauty products with a combined retail value of $139.
Walmart bets on mystery boxes
A mystery box is part of a longstanding trend called “uncertainty marketing.”
“A common retail application of uncertainty marketing is ‘blind box collectibles,’ which use opaque packaging to conceal the individual product variant within an advertised collection. The tactic has a long history, with the application being traced back to the 1870s, when randomly inserted trading cards were included in the sale of tobacco,” according to the January 2025 academic article Eye-opening! Exploring Uncertainty Marketing Through Hedonic Blind Box Collectibles.
FabFitFun explained its philosophy.
“Designed around the thrill of discovery that has long been at the heart of the FabFitFun experience, the Holiday Mystery Beauty Box spans cosmetics, skincare and haircare, bringing together established favorites and emerging beauty brands at an accessible price point,” the company shared.
The challenge, however, is that when you buy tobacco, the baseball card was a bonus. If you don’t like the player or want the card, you still got the product you purchased.
More Walmart:
- Walmart faces FTC scrutiny over AI-era personalized pricing
- Walmart has a new plan to solve one of its customers’ biggest problems
- Walmart copies a core Costco move that also benefits customers
In this case, Walmart and FabFitFun are betting that shoppers will like enough of the mystery box contents to make the expense seem worth the price.
Back when I was getting my quarterly mystery box, about 75% of the items went right in the trash.
But because it was a gift, the bar was lower for an overall enjoyable experience — every box had at least one thing I was excited to get.

Shutterstock
Walmart bets on mystery boxes as a deal
“At a time when affordability is increasingly important, our partnership with Walmart allows us to extend that promise to more shoppers with exclusive, limited-time offerings that make great gifting more accessible for the holidays,” said Daniel Broukhim, co-CEO of FabFitFun.
GlobalData Managing Director Neil Saunders commented on mystery boxes on his LinkedIn page.
“The trend chimes with the Gen Z and Millennial desire for collecting things and their general interest in Asian culture. However, it is also part of a pattern of some consumers seeking little points of added excitement when they self-indulge. The mystery adds to the experience.”
As inflation and tariffs push up the prices of many everyday products, some consumers may view blind boxes as mini-luxuries or affordable treats, Noah Eisemann, global managing director of social and influencer at VML, told Marketing Brew.
Brands, however, may have another motive for using blind boxes.
“Blind boxes can also provide an opportunity for brands with higher price points to reach customers with smaller budgets. Athleisure brand Set Active, streetwear brand Madhappy, and cookware brand Le Creuset are among the retailers that have used mystery boxes to help clear out inventory at lower price points,” Marketing Brew shared.
RTM Nexus CEO Dominick Miserandino sees the mystery box as an excellent gift.
“A beauty mystery box solves a very real holiday problem: You know they like beauty products, but you have no idea what they’d pick. FabFitFun gives Walmart shoppers a name they can trust to pick what goes in the box, and Walmart gives FabFitFun a chance to reach people who’d never sign up for a subscription,” he told TheStreet.
The box itself, however, has to deliver.
“The risk is that a mystery box is only fun if what’s inside feels like a good deal after you open it. If they get that right, it’s the kind of gift people buy for someone else and then go back for one themselves,” Miserandino added.
Related: Walmart shares delivery update consumers need to know about